Monday, February 25, 2013
Valentine day as freedom to love
Wednesday, December 19, 2012
Sociology of Academics in Nepal
Sociology of Academics in Nepal
Being relatively a new fish on the pond of academia, I am yet to understand deeply the reason behind the sorry state of our oldest and largest academic institution. Being a part of Tribhuvan University fills me both with sense of pride and feeling of helplessness. While acquiring a new identity of lecturer, I am gradually realizing that academics are perhaps the most blamed professionals in Nepal. They are blamed by students for not teaching well, not being updated enough in recent debates. Proponents of Academic NGOs repeatedly question their quality of academic contributions. Media blames them for overt politicization of academic institutions. The very politicians, who covet intellectuals to bring under their fold, lament on the scarcity of "true intellectuals". Indeed, academics in Nepal are more or less accountable for these allegations against them. In the midst of this blame game, we often commit mistake of lumping all academics in a single category. If we observe, we may find that Nepal probably has the most diverse species of academics produced by the sorry state of academic institutions. The relationship between the origin of diversity of academics and sorry state of academic institution is like a chicken or egg question. The question remains, which comes first.
Particularly, my observations are based on Tribhuvan University which seems like an overcrowded train gradually halting in its speed and nearly being dismantled out of its academic track. These categorizations are based on observations and numerous conversations that I have had with fellow academics and other professionals over the years. While I go on with categorizations, I am not claiming that these identities are absolute and fixed. In some cases, these categories may be seen as phases that an academic may pass through or at times, an academic may just be stuck in a limbo in between identities.
The first noticeable species are celebrity academics. The ones who had substantially contributed to academic knowledge in past but in present trying to live off the fruits of yesteryears. They are much coveted by INGOs who continue to use their consultancy services. They write bland research reports but produce nothing that contributes to academic knowledge. Sometimes they appear in op-ed pages in newspaper to reinforce the belief that their old theoretical perspectives are still relevant. Another noticeable group is activist academics who struggle with the challenge to manage their dual identities. Few of them are somehow able to perform this tightrope act and are creating new landmarks for academics in Nepal. But many of these activist academics are gradually turning into more activists than academics. And they have begun to produce similar rheoritic like political leaders and NGO workers.
The other kinds are real academics who are actively engaged in teaching and research. They have fascinating conversations with their students, often beyond classrooms. They are often the victim of the politicized system which requires academics to do chakari to netas and take refuge under certain political umbrella. These academics resist and continue to prod on the exhilarating journey of quest for knowledge. And in the front of their very eyes, their lesser counterparts with less vision and academic rigor go ahead being Department Heads, Deans and VCs. These visionary people, who have convictions and ideas for necessary initiatives required to transform the institution, remain relegated to marginality. But they do not give up, they continue to contribute, engage in discourses. They appear in radio, television and newspapers sometimes. They continue to create a ripple with their perspectives and ideas.
The next species right among us but not so obvious are cloak academics. They use identity of academics as a cloak because they are not able to embrace the true meaning of their profession, either by choice or lack of ability. Thus, they substitute their lack of academic rigor by being engaged in other activities. The major field of their involvement is definitely politics. Obviously academics do have political beliefs on personal level. They do need to be involved in occupation based organizations to safeguard their rights. But the question remains unanswered why academics need so many different professors' association? Apart from politicos, other cloak academics are engaged in different activities ranging from investing in private colleges to working as real estate brokers. Cloak academics however continue to teach as they need to draw salary from their regular jagir. They recycle their knowledge based on their old notes, which seems to be faded with use. They don't find it important to update themselves in recent changes in academic discourses. They talk and they want students to listen attentively. Some even, pretending to help the students, bring written notes into the classroom and recite them while students write every word. One wonders why don't they simply handover these notes to students who can easily photocopy them at once and read at home. But then, one can fathom that for them, the classes without notes will be akin to travelling in a new city without a map.
Others are new generation academics, a new species that have recently started to inhabit classrooms of our oldest academic institution. Curious glances and whispers track their movements and scrutinize their attire. Bursting with ideas and believers of change, these new generation academics struggle with the system that refuses to accommodate the energy and vigor they have. They feel uncomfortable in highly politicized academic arena. They feel at loss of words in office meeting rooms among the old generation academics, where discussion on academic discourses is nonexistent. Always carrying backpacks with their laptop, they seek space somewhere to write, to research. But an age old entry requirement of university system continues to banish them. These new generation academics are often relegated o the status of amsik lecturers who try to contribute more than so called thai full time teachers. Faced with the challenge of livelihood, they are unsure about the direction of their future. They continue to ask themselves and people around them how long are they to continue in hope of being established in a profession that they are qualified and so interested in. They often draw their livelihood from other engagements. But they are most happy when they are in university: teaching, researching and writing.
The other category, helmet teacher is already discussed much in public discourses. Helmet teachers have been much blamed and ridiculed. However, I see nothing to fault them. Their numbers are likely to grow even more if we see the continuity of mushrooming private college affiliates of same university minus the lack of increase in academic spirit promised by the advertisements in big billboards and full front page in newspapers.
Looking at these categories, many species of academics have been able to work their way around own personal benefit, making the most of the sorry state of academic institutions in Nepal. These academics are equally to blame along with the meddling politicians for the deterioration of Tribhuvan University. But there is still hope. We still have academics around us who have potential to transform the institutions, if we recognize them and entrust them with responsibilities and opportunities. So, next time if we hear anybody about to start fresh batch of accusations against academics of Nepal, we could perhaps interrupt and ask. Which species of academic are you talking about, could you please be specific?
Wednesday, October 3, 2012
The Search
I am tired
With this facade of being nice, always
But in this crooked world
One can only keep the mask on
And pretend that all is well.
So, what others see me
Is actually not me
This nice, gentle woman
Who smiles
And talks with little frown on her face.
You are the one,
Who knows
How I am deep within
With you, I can sometimes lash out
All those frustrations
I have Bottled up inside my heart.
Sometimes, I just try to hide in the shell
And pretend as if all is well
But you with your eyes
Seek me out and see through me
With you I cannot pretend.
I can sometimes act like a bitch
And have no qualms about it
Sometimes I have these phases
Its hormones mostly
But sometimes its me
A minute angry
A minute happy
A minute the tears come
A minute laughing hysterically.
And how can I show this self to the world.
They would think I am mad, perhaps I am.
With you,
I can be little mad
A little sad
A little angry
A little funny
A little cranky
A little swanky
A little gloomy
Coz that's what I am like
Always not so smart
A little loose in the head
With all the crazy thoughts
Going back and forth.
Sometimes, I live in a cloud
And forget to switch off the gas
And burn the curry down.
I know its not easy
Being with me.
Its not easy
Actually living with me
Day in and Day out.
I do not know where this poem is going
I should end this soon….
This little frolicking of my mind
Which is content
That life long search is in end.
It took me so long to realize
A treasure was right in front of me
But I was searching everywhere
when I started
I stumbled a lot
Knocked some wrong doors
And few trespassers wanted to enter
Through window.
But it seems,"the end"
Is actually not an end.
With each new phase
I know you more
And still feel
There is more to know
You are like a Russian doll
With each find, there is something more inside
I keep on uncovering and finding.
So, the search did not end.
It only changed its direction
Saturday, September 22, 2012
Parent's quest for quality education
Teej: negotiating between modernity and tradition
Saturday, April 14, 2012
Happy New Year 2069
Year's end is neither an end nor a beginning but a going on, with all the wisdom that experience can instill in us. - Har Barland
Tuesday, April 3, 2012
Experience of Nepali women in Academia
Experience of Nepali women in Academia
Tuesday, December 6, 2011
Motherhood: guilt and dreams
From morning To night
I rush through life
That is a chaos
Created on my own choice
I know my precious one
You want me
Just to be with you
Hold your hand
Cradle you into sleep
Just to be with you
And marvel at your
Gestures that you learn everyday
The first instance you smiled
The first words you uttered
The first step you took
You want me
To play with you
And be like you
Innocent, full of marvel
And wonder at the world
But somehow I am caught up
In this web of responsibilities and obligations
Everything has become a “task”
To get over with
To complete
To finish
Sometimes even caring for you
Becomes a mere activity
But today my dear
I leave everything
I close my computer
Turn off my phone
And just take that walk
I have wanted to take since long
I will walk with you outside the door
Holding your little hands
I will let you take me
where you want
I will be beside you
To see things that you discover
and point out in the way
I might forget camera
But I will remember
Your pure, selfless smile
In my heart
And keep it there
To keep me sane enough
To rejoin the crazy hectic world again
Sunday, December 4, 2011
Seminars in Nepal: Mr. Know Alls, Ramblers and Super Experts
Seminars in Nepal: Mr. Know Alls, Ramblers and Super Experts
In Nepal, we do not have frequent number of academic seminars as we would like. Most of them are usually organized by NGO wallas, this invites a mixture of people from all different sorts of backgrounds and involvement. I would like to focus more on presenter and audience interaction that happens during the seminars and conferences.
One of the important factors for presenter to attend academic conference is to get an opportunity to present one’s work among a larger group of audience with diverse academic experience and interest. One expects to get some form of feedback, suggestions and ideas and possibly get to know people who are doing something similar.
The most distressing thing for presenter is to be asked question by an audience who hardly paid attention during presentation. These audience often ask repetitive question which have already been spoken by the presenter. I have often witnessed presenters being drilled with harsh criticisms and comments, which are often personal. Audience should be able to comment in an objective way focusing on the content of presentation. Due to these problems, presenters are often forced to present in defensive note. Based on observation of some of conferences I attended, I identify three different groups of audience based on the nature of interaction with the presenter.
Almost all of us have encountered Mr. Know all (in Nepal it is hard to find Mrs. Know all as very few women audiences speak during interaction session) whose main aim is to show just how smart they are. They have opinion on everything, which is not bad thing actually as long as it is based on some form of research and life experiences. Sometimes Mr. Know Alls are bent to embarrass the presenters by making remarks about the inadequacy of presenter’s work. They often comment that the presenter has not covered certain aspect which they think is important. Mr. Know Alls, fail to see that each research has its own limitations and has a certain way of inquiring into subject matter. Often these people comment that presenter’s data is too small and again fail to recall that the presenter said it was qualitative research. These Mr. Know Alls also fail to see that however broader the presenter’s research may be, due to time limitation of the presentation, presenters can hardly cover everything that they are investigating. Thus, it would be more effective if Mr. Know Alls contemplate on what they know first based on their research and life experience, then only venture to ask questions.
Another regular characters of Nepali seminars are Babblers. They stand up, give their introduction and begin to babble for next 5-10 minutes. The presenter and other people the moderator on the panel make a futile attempt to redirect this Babbler but without success. A lengthy monologue ends and presenter is forced to ask the Babbler again ‘what is it that you asked?’ Which of course is about to prompt the Babbler to speak for next few minutes with an intellectual smirk in his face. Fortunately, one of the panelists come to rescue and asks one ready made question on behalf of our Babbler. So, these Babblers are keen for limelight, they want to show they can speak but hardly they make a plan about what and why they are speaking for. Babblers sometimes bring interesting twist to conference but often they embarrass other people and themselves by such behavior. It would be great if Babblers formulate a clear question they wish to ask and re-check if it is anywhere relevant to presenter’s work.
Another brand of audience we can see is Super Expert. Normally, expert means having expertise in particular area and subject. However, this Super Expert we often encounter in conferences professes and pretends to be expert in almost everything that is even slightly related to their area. They have exclude image of authority and diffuse a certain air of intellectuality. They regards it their duty to inform, dissect and suggest anyone who happens to be presenting. Their targeted victims are usually fresh graduates and wannabes researcher. Super expert’s major objective of participating in seminar and conference is to assert their importance and contribution in their field. It would be great if Super Expert reflect on their own past when they presented in a seminar with their trembling heart and fluttering hands.
There may be more than these three groups of audiences that I have encountered till date. I am not saying that these kinds of audience are altogether wrong in their approach. What I am intending to show is that the audience should give a minimum level of credibility to presenter for his/her efforts. The inquiry should be directed in such a way that would help both audience and presenter to broaden their knowledge in particular area they are interested in. The discussion session will be more fruitful if an audience asks in such a way that enables presenters to clarify his subject area more broadly, which might have been left out in presentation. With this discussion, I am bracing myself up for my next presentation and curious about what other kinds of audience I would encounter in future.
Thursday, November 17, 2011
Parenting experience in Nepal
Note: this article was published on Kathmandu post dated 13th November 2011, available in following link http://epaper.ekantipur.com/kt
When kids become sick: Dhup batti, Abipattikar churna and Azithromycin
-Dadhiram Khanal and Neeti Aryal Khanal
Ask any parent about their worst experience. Child’s sickness: that will be their definite answer. Didn’t we believe during those early happy days of a new parent, that dealing with dirty nappies/diapers and wailing at midnight is only for couple of years? After that, we were supposed to be as carefree as before. But soon enough we know that children, sick at any age are handful. So, extend your deadlines, postpone your weekend plans and forget your favorite TV shows. Your mobile is suddenly in control of little hands, and you are in no position to protest or negotiate. Don’t be surprised if your colleague calls you in not so pleasant voice and ask about numerous missed calls and blank messages. Don’t let weird ringtones and peculiar profile settings deter you either.
The issues that we are discussing in this article may not be representative for all Nepali parents. But chance meeting and sharing with parents in waiting rooms in hospital confirms that many middle class working parents undergo similar dilemmas and experiences.
First of all, when a child becomes sick, the first thing we usually do is search for reasons. Ask any doctor, one of the definite answers will be germs or virus. Many of previous generation of our parents strongly believe on influence of food habits and perhaps some of them even believe in concept of “evil eye”, ankha lagne. Thus, modern ajabholika Nepali parents like us have a unique way of looking at and dealing with children’s sickness. Here, we share the whole emotional drama of parent’s lives surrounding children’s sickness.
Investigation for reasons starts every time our five year old son starts coughing or sneezing. Was that the fistful of chocolate he ate coaxing his hajurama? Or was it the whole bottle of cold water he insisted in drinking claiming that he was too thirsty for warm water? Or was it because he was playing outside in cold evening without his cap? So it goes on. After the end of this mini-research, we start rehearsing an agreed version of “what went wrong” to retell it to the inquiring neighbors, relatives and pediatrician we may soon visit. But often, we are too troubled by the little one’s misery and discomfort that we do not know what to say.
The most recurring debate surrounding children’s treatment is over the merit of Ayurvedic vs Allopathic medicine. In our home, it occurs in divergent intensity depending on the level of the sickness. Our son’s hajurbuwa strongly believes in the power of the herbs and he himself is somewhat a self taught kabiraj. Often, visiting relatives swear by his self prepared concoction, Pachak to cure any tummy problem of kids and adults. Even our mother says that “kabiraj” medicine though working slowly always goes to the root of the problem whereas doctor’s medicine does not. So, mild sicknesses are often convincingly cured by some churna, bati and ras.
Sometimes, you are caught unaware when kids fall seriously ill often at the most hectic week at your work, as it happens with us now and then. We visit our trusted Pediatrician, who really listens. He seldom snatches his pad for hasty prescription of antibiotics within two minutes of consultation. But in serious illness, one has to give in to antibiotics despite all that apprehensive feeling of a parent on its supposedly negative effects. We have often heard few parents’ emotional turmoil over wrong diagnosis, sometimes at cost of child’s health. Often, parents consult multiple doctors all in good faith but are terribly confused with divergent diagnosis.
So, going back to our household drama, hajurama just doesn’t trust on power of kabiraj and doctor saab alone. For her dear naati, she is willing to go an extra mile and hail over all gods and goddesses she knows. Thus, usually the treatment starts with chants of mantra along with lighting Nepali paper incense, Bateko dhup and moving it over the body of the sick child. Definitely reminds us of some shamanic rituals of yesteryears, isn’t it? Earlier as new parents, we regarded it as useless superstitious gesture. But with time, we have learnt to accept and respect her efforts. Firstly, it makes her feel better that she is doing something worthwhile for recovery of her grandchild. Secondly, even our son is emotionally strengthened by his hajurama’s selfless efforts. Thirdly, may be somewhere out there god is really listening to us. Then grandpa joins in with his recommendation of some churna, bati and ras. But in times of prolonging sickness, hajurbuwa gives in to doctor sab’s Azithromycin. But definitely, he would soon start his ayurvedic practice after this bout of illness is over. His concern is on building immunity power of his nati. Soon the daily dosage of lip smacking Chyawanparash and not so yummy Abipattikar churna will start under hajurbuwa’s careful supervision.
And then, after about a week of sleepless nights and mobileless days, we go back to our normal selves. Of course, there will be chocolates, cold water and lot of playing without the cap on, all behind our back. After few months, there will be a cough here and a sneeze there. Then we know it would be time to roll up our sleeves, give up our mobiles and get ready for another roller coaster ride that parenting entails.
Disclaimer: The medicines discussed in the article are used as example only and in no way should be understood as prescribed medicines.
As parents of two children, the writers love to discuss different issues relating to parenting in Nepal. They can be reached at apednepal@gmail.com.